Identifying Critical Design Parameters for Improved Body Temperature Measurements: A Clinical Study Comparing Transient and Predicted Temperature Measurements

Readily available store brand, or “home,” thermometers are used countless times in the home and clinic as a first diagnostic measure of body temperature. Measurement inaccuracies may lead to unnecessary medical visits or medication (false positives), or, potentially worse, lack of intervention when a person is truly sick (false negatives). A critical first step in the design process is to determine the shortcomings of the existing designs. For this project, we evaluated the accuracy of three currently available store brand thermometers in a pediatric population. The accuracies of the thermometers were assessed by comparing their body temperature predictions to those measured by a specially designed and calibrated and fast-responding reference thermometer. The reference thermometer was placed at the measurement site simultaneously with the store brand thermometer and recorded the temperature at the measurement site co ntinuously. More than 300 healthy or sick pediatric subjects were enrolled in this study. Temperatures were measured at both the oral and axillary (under the arm) sites. The store brand thermometer measurements characteristically deviated from the reference thermometer temperature after 120 s, and the deviations did not follow a consistent pattern. The Brand C thermometers had the greatest deviations of up to 3.7 °F (2.1 °C), while the Brand A thermometers had the lowest deviations; however, they still deviated by up to 1.9 °F (1.1 °C). The data...
Source: Journal of Medical Devices, Transactions of the ASME - Category: Medical Devices Source Type: research